Pages

Saturday, February 23, 2019

Polio

The first large field trial of Jonas Salk’s polio vaccine began on this date in 1954.
Salk said: “Our greatest responsibility is to be good ancestors.”
Outbreaks of poliomyelitis were first recorded more than a thousand years ago. The incurable disease is caused by a virus that attacks nerve cells and sometimes even the central nervous system itself; it causes muscle weakness and wasting, paralysis, and sometimes death. It didn’t kill as many people as other viruses like influenza, but it was highly contagious and it was difficult to determine how it was transmitted. Children were most often affected. The first major polio outbreak in the United States struck in 1894, near Rutland, Vermont; the virus claimed its most famous victim in 1921, when Franklin Delano Roosevelt contracted it after a swim. His legs were completely paralyzed. Roosevelt helped found an organization — originally called the National Foundation on Infantile Paralysis, but later the March of Dimes — to research and combat the disease.
Dr. Jonas Salk was leading the Virus Research Lab at the University of Pittsburgh when the March of Dimes approached him in 1947. They asked him to lead efforts to research and develop an effective vaccine. He discovered there were about 125 different strains of the polio virus; these could be grouped into three basic types. A vaccine needed to provide immunity to all three types to be considered effective. Salk gathered many different strains of the virus and “killed” or deactivated them by pouring formaldehyde on them. The dead but intact virus was then injected into a subject, whose body would begin to produce antibodies against the virus; the antibodies would enable the body to fight off any future infections. Salk tested the vaccine on monkeys first, and then began the first human trials in 1952. His chief competitor, Albert Sabin, was working on a live-virus form of the vaccine; Sabin claimed Salk’s vaccine wasn’t strong enough and called him “a mere kitchen chemist.” But Sabin’s vaccine took a long time to develop, and was still unstable, so the March of Dimes backed Salk’s method instead. Salk was so confident in the safety of his vaccine that he used himself and his children as early test subjects. All of them, including several other adult volunteers, produced antibodies to the virus without contracting polio.
By this time, there was tremendous pressure to find an effective way to control the disease: 1952 saw the worst outbreak in America’s history, with nearly 60,000 cases reported; more than 3,000 people died and more than 21,000 were left disabled. Salk knew that he needed to begin testing his vaccine on a large scale, and quickly. He set up a makeshift lab in the gymnasium of Arsenal Elementary School in Pittsburgh, and personally administered his vaccine to 137 schoolkids. A month later, he announced that the first trial was a success, and he soon expanded his efforts across the country. By the time the vaccine was announced to be safe and effective in 1955, 1.8 million schoolchildren had received the vaccine. Results showed that about 65 percent of test subjects became immune to poliovirus type 1, 90 percent to type 2, and 94 percent to type 3. It marked the beginning of the end of widespread polio outbreaks. The development and approval of Sabin’s competing oral vaccine, which was cheaper and easier to administer, advanced the cause even further.
Soon after the 1954 trials began, the New York Times reported, “This could mean that within the next three to five years polio, crippler of young and old alike, will join diphtheria, smallpox, typhoid and other formerly dreaded infectious diseases as plagues finally tamed and conquered by man.” In 1952, 60,000 people contracted polio in the United States alone; 60 years later, in 2012, polio cases numbered only 223 in the entire world. WA

7 comments:

  1. It blows my mind how technically evolved we are as a species regarding our ability to handle infectious disease. The fact that we are able to mitigate outbreaks of destructive diseases to the point of temporary extinction stands as a powerful testament to our power as humans. Regardless of your opinion on the efficacy of said vaccines, their overall benevolent impact on society cannot go unnoticed.

    DQ:
    Do you think the study and implementation of the polio vaccine would have been as successful without becoming "famous" due to President Roosevelt?
    What kind of backlash would a similar study being conducted in modern day America receive, particularly regarding being in the age of social media?
    Would you be willing to volunteer in such an experimental study?
    Do you think that the cooperative possibility of disease outbreaks being avoidable has anything to do with parental motive to discourage vaccinations?
    If people are going to inevitably reject vaccines (and therefore spread the disease to those who have also not been vaccinated), should there be regulations in effect to guarantee minimal contact between the unvaccinated?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the parental motives are mostly ignorance and fear. Not sure I understand how the possibility of avoiding epidemics would motivate anti-vaxers...

      Could we legally and in conscience permanently quarantine the unvaccinated? Probably not. It wouldn't be fair to the kids, in any case, who had no say in the matter.

      Delete
    2. I agree that we could not quarantine them due to the fairness of the children. But considering this, what could we do to better spread the importance of vaccinating in a way that would that would benefit the children who have no choice?

      Delete
  2. I agree with you in that it is amazing how we are able to bring viruses to extinction. This has great benefit to our society as many more people who are here now would be dead if it was not for the prevention of viruses. If we were not able to harness this ability, society would drastically change from the one we currently live in. Some influential people who have led movements or shaped society in some way may possibly have never done so if we could not prevent diseases. Saying this, the ability to eradicate or maintain some diseases has greatly changed and benefited society and will continue to do so.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that the speed at which the polio vaccine was successfully created and implemented can partially be accredited to Theodore Roosevelt's involvement. If it was not for him, I believe the polio vaccine would have taken a much longer time to create as the researchers would not have the funding that was granted to them by the March of Dimes. It could even be that the polio research and vaccine could have been completely abandoned due to lack of funds if it wasn't for the March of Dimes that originated with Theodore Roosevelt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. FDR you mean, not his robustly vigorous distant cousin TR.

      Delete
    2. You are very right. Accidentally switched the names while typing.

      Delete