For my first installment I will begin
to discuss some of the many dilemmas surrounding the genetically modified foods
issue and the upcoming dilemma about lab grown food. I will begin by discussing
what’s actually being added to our animal and plant products. The FDA only
approves the use of six hormones in agriculture. Three of the hormones on this list
are naturally occurring hormones: estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone.
The other three “hormones” on the FDA’s list are man-made chemicals that they “proved”
are safe for human consumption: zeranol, trenbolone acetate and melengesterol
acetate. The reason I put proved in quotation marks is because according to
their website, “The FDA approves these drugs only after information and/or
studies have shown that the food from the treated animals is safe for people to
eat, and that the drugs do not harm the treated animal or the environment. The
drugs also have to work as intended.” This statement seems to contradict many studies
done on the effects of these hormones. Many studies show that prolonged
overexposure to these hormones leads to cancers and other health problems such
as diabetes and obesity. It makes me curious how their research findings seem
to deem these hormones safe while numerous other researchers come to an opposite
conclusion.
Though
the FDA deems these hormones and chemicals safe for human consumption while
other researchers oppose these finding based off of their own findings, for now
it is still unknown of what all long term effects that are caused by these
hormones. Many researchers are beginning to link exposure to these hormones to
many illnesses such as various forms of cancer, obesity, diabetes, and endometriosis.
The main purpose of these studies is to get these chemicals listed as
carcinogens, cancer causing agents, and therefore get them removed from the FDA
approved lists. Such findings for estradiol has been discussed in Europe which
has led to the substance being banned in Europe for years, yet it is still
allowed for use in the United States. However, it is hard to find definitive
evidence of the effects of the hormones on human because trials concerning this
type of research is deemed, rightfully so, unethical.
Two of
the most prominent hormone/chemicals added to animals currently is estrogen and
steroids. Two substances that are not even on the FDA’s list but it commonly in
chickens and cows on many farms throughout the United States to increase growth
and in cow’s case also to increase milk production. Many scientific investigations
show that prolonged exposure to estrogen leads to breast cancer. While eating
meats and drinking milk from steroid injected cows can lead to prostate and
colon cancer. Though as of right now this is just speculation these outcomes
could be caused by a third-party variable that we have not accounted for. Until
it is proven one way or another we should play it safe and outlaw things that
research linked to be unsafe.
Another
urgent concern to me is synthetic or artificial versions of these hormones that
are used in the industry. For example, diethylstilbestrol (DES), a synthetic
version of estrogen, was found that it amplified the risk of vaginal cancer in
women that were exposed to the estrogen variant.
Though
with various evidence that can lead one to question whether these hormones and
additives are safe, the general public is not aware of the possible dangers in
the grocery stores fast-food restaurants. When they go to their local grocery
store and enter the meat section of the store they are greeted two prominent
options. Option one is a FDA approved chicken breast while option two is an
organic chicken breast. The organic option is advertised to be healthier for you,
but the FDA approved option is twice the size and half the cost. Growing up I would
always wonder why someone would rather pay double the price for a piece of meat
that half the amount. For the average consumer it is becoming increasingly
harder to eat natural food with the cost of organic foods rising, so the logical
option for most people is to get the most out of their dollar and purchase the
meat approved by their government.
"Until it is proven one way or another we should play it safe and outlaw things that research linked to be unsafe" - agreed. Trouble is, there are large corporate interests with a huge financial stake in not adopting a precautionary approach, and lots of politicians in their pockets.
ReplyDelete"For the average consumer it is becoming increasingly harder to eat natural food with the cost of organic foods rising" -
true, but on the other hand Michael Pollan argues persuasively that the long-term costs of cheaper eating ultimately mitigate the short-term cost-savings. He does agree, though, that organic meat may be prohibitive for some:
"Q: Our family is on a budget and can’t afford to eat all organic. Where should we direct our money to get the most benefit? Organic produce? Meats? Dairy?
A: This was the most popular question by far, and it’s a good one: some organic products offer the consumer more value than others, so if you’re on a budget, it’s important to buy organic strategically. Here are a few quick rules of thumb:
If you have young kids, it’s worth paying the organic premium on whatever they eat or drink the most of organically. So if they drink lots of apple juice — which they shouldn’t, by the way — or milk, then spring for it there.
On produce, some items, when grown conventionally, have more pesticide residue than others, so when buying these, it pays to buy organic. According to the Environmental Working Group, the “dirty dozen” most pesticide-laden fruits and vegetables are: apples, celery, strawberries, peaches, spinach, imported nectarines, imported grapes, sweet bell peppers, potatoes, blueberries, lettuce and kale/collars. The “clean 15” are onions, sweet corn, pineapples, avocado, asparagus, sweet peas, mangoes, eggplant, cantaloupe, kiwi, cabbage, watermelon, sweet potatoes, grapefruit and mushrooms. So if you’ve only got a little money to devote to organic, buy the organic apples and skip the organic onions. But do keep in mind that it’s important to eat fruits and vegetables regardless of how they’re grown.
In meat, organic is very expensive, and doesn’t necessarily ensure that the animals didn’t live on feedlot. I look for grass fed for beef instead, milk and butter, too."
https://michaelpollan.com/articles-archive/michael-pollan-answers-readers-questions/
DeleteI think the entire food industry is a train-wreck. Beyond the added hormones, we also need to confront the incredible amount of antibiotics used to basically allow farmers to forgo healthy homes for their livestock. Animals are pumped with antibiotics to keep them from getting sick, while we end up with e coli washing down onto the crops. On top of that, some studies are verifying that the use of antibiotics are leading to treatment-resistant super bugs. Why are we doing this? We're not only disrespecting the animals and our planet, but we're sacrificing the well-being of our own species for a quick profit. I'm definitely motivated to be better committed to eating organic thanks to your post and excellent research.
ReplyDeleteOn piggies and super bugs:
http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/09/are-antibiotics-turning-livestock-superbug-factories
https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2017/04/pork-antibiotics-kfc/