PHIL 3345. Supporting the philosophical study of bioethics, bio-medical ethics, biotechnology, and the future of life, at Middle Tennessee State University and beyond... "Keep your health, your splendid health. It is better than all the truths under the firmament." William James
Monday, February 23, 2015
Memory Enhancement
Study Guide
Study for the exam by re-reading and reflecting on relevant texts, NOT by rote memorization. Prepare your extra-credit response in advance by printing your reply to the DQ of your choice, just a couple of paragraphs will suffice. Bring it with you on Thursday.
1. What is the difference between (normal) medical care and palliative care? (BB104)
1. What is the difference between (normal) medical care and palliative care? (BB104)
Answer: medical care focuses on cure and diagnosis and palliative care focuses on the comfort of terminal patients.
2.What code was drawn up after WWII and states "The health of my patient will be my first consideration."? (BB80)
Answer: The Geneva Code of Medical Ethics
3.What were the five religions discussed by the author of Bioethics: The Basics? (BB63)
Answer: Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism
4. What is preventive medicine? (BB138)
Answer: a field that devises measures to prevent and control disease
5. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades? (AP25)
Answer: admiration
6. Chapter 3 begins by asking if our bioethical perspective ("vision") is skewed by ______... (BB48)
(a) cultural assumptions, (b) gender bias, (c) religious faith, (d) all of the above
Answer: D
7.What doctrine requires that all research protocols must be submitted to a "research ethics committe before the study begins"? (BB117)
Answer: Helsinki Declaration
8. What is a biobank? (BB133)
Answer: a collection of biological samples or genetic information
9. What are the three types of valid consent? (BB83)
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary
10. The idea that the doctor always knows best is called what? (BB82)
Answer Paternalism
2.What code was drawn up after WWII and states "The health of my patient will be my first consideration."? (BB80)
Answer: The Geneva Code of Medical Ethics
3.What were the five religions discussed by the author of Bioethics: The Basics? (BB63)
Answer: Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism
4. What is preventive medicine? (BB138)
Answer: a field that devises measures to prevent and control disease
5. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades? (AP25)
Answer: admiration
6. Chapter 3 begins by asking if our bioethical perspective ("vision") is skewed by ______... (BB48)
(a) cultural assumptions, (b) gender bias, (c) religious faith, (d) all of the above
Answer: D
7.What doctrine requires that all research protocols must be submitted to a "research ethics committe before the study begins"? (BB117)
Answer: Helsinki Declaration
8. What is a biobank? (BB133)
Answer: a collection of biological samples or genetic information
9. What are the three types of valid consent? (BB83)
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary
10. The idea that the doctor always knows best is called what? (BB82)
Answer Paternalism
Posted by Andrew Nolin
==
. The _________ required that 'The health of my patient must be my first consideration.' (Hippocratic Oath, Geneva Code, British Medical Association, International Association of Bioethics)
Answer: Hippocratic Oath (BB 2)
2. What are the three types of valid consent for human participation in research?
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary (BB 83)
3. Sandel's deepest moral objection to enhancement is its alleged disfigurement of what relation?
Answer: parent-child relationship (pg. 46)
Rory CapstickFebruary 23, 2015 at 12:06 PM
4. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades?
5. How do Ritalin, Adderall etc differ from recreational drugs of the past?
Answer: Hippocratic Oath (BB 2)
2. What are the three types of valid consent for human participation in research?
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary (BB 83)
3. Sandel's deepest moral objection to enhancement is its alleged disfigurement of what relation?
Answer: parent-child relationship (pg. 46)
Rory CapstickFebruary 23, 2015 at 12:06 PM
4. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades?
5. How do Ritalin, Adderall etc differ from recreational drugs of the past?
Sunday, February 22, 2015
Group 3 Vaccination Project
My group chose vaccination as our midterm project, and my task is to
describe the pros of getting vaccinated. I will talk about the top
reasons to get vaccinated, namely the benefits to one’s health and lifestyle
and to society as a whole. The number of
communicable diseases in developed countries has plummeted dramatically within
the past century, which has contributed to an overall increase in the standard
of living and productivity of the citizens within those countries. Not only are people living healthier, disease-free
lives, they are able to live longer and get sick less often since they are
under attack by fewer disease causing agents.
This saves them time as well as money, as they are not having to recover
from major illness as often as past generations and they are able to miss less
work in doing so. Also, those who get vaccinated are able to protect those
unable to receive the vaccine, whether due to an allergy to the ingredients or
some other valid reason. By having so
little opportunity to infect individuals and spread, a disease is neutralized
through herd immunity if a high enough percentage of the population is
protected against that disease. However,
this barrier begins to break down once enough people stop becoming immunized. This chink in the armor of protection against
disease allows enough room for a disease to infect the unprotected and possibly
mutate around the vaccine, so that everyone is at risk. Also, it is much easier to isolate a single
case than to stop an uncontrolled spread, which is yet another reason for as
many people as possible to be protected.
All these reasons and more will comprise my portion of our project on
Thursday.


Exam 1 Study Guide (Group 3)
1. What is the difference between (normal) medical care and palliative care? (BB104)
Answer: medical care focuses on cure and diagnosis and palliative care focuses on the comfort of terminal patients.
2.What code was drawn up after WWII and states "The health of my patient will be my first consideration."? (BB80)
Answer: The Geneva Code of Medical Ethics
3.What were the five religions discussed by the author of Bioethics: The Basics? (BB63)
Answer: Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism
4. What is preventive medicine? (BB138)
Answer: a field that devises measures to prevent and control disease
5. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades? (AP25)
Answer: admiration
6. Chapter 3 begins by asking if our bioethical perspective ("vision") is skewed by ______... (BB48)
(a) cultural assumptions, (b) gender bias, (c) religious faith, (d) all of the above
Answer: D
7.What doctrine requires that all research protocols must be submitted to a "research ethics committe before the study begins"? (BB117)
Answer: Helsinki Declaration
8. What is a biobank? (BB133)
Answer: a collection of biological samples or genetic information
9. What are the three types of valid consent? (BB83)
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary
10. The idea that the doctor always knows best is called what? (BB82)
Answer Paternalism
Answer: medical care focuses on cure and diagnosis and palliative care focuses on the comfort of terminal patients.
2.What code was drawn up after WWII and states "The health of my patient will be my first consideration."? (BB80)
Answer: The Geneva Code of Medical Ethics
3.What were the five religions discussed by the author of Bioethics: The Basics? (BB63)
Answer: Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism
4. What is preventive medicine? (BB138)
Answer: a field that devises measures to prevent and control disease
5. As athletic enhancement increases, what fades? (AP25)
Answer: admiration
6. Chapter 3 begins by asking if our bioethical perspective ("vision") is skewed by ______... (BB48)
(a) cultural assumptions, (b) gender bias, (c) religious faith, (d) all of the above
Answer: D
7.What doctrine requires that all research protocols must be submitted to a "research ethics committe before the study begins"? (BB117)
Answer: Helsinki Declaration
8. What is a biobank? (BB133)
Answer: a collection of biological samples or genetic information
9. What are the three types of valid consent? (BB83)
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary
10. The idea that the doctor always knows best is called what? (BB82)
Answer Paternalism
Group 1 Test Questions
1. The _________ required that 'The health of my patient must be my first consideration.' (Hippocratic Oath, Geneva Code, British Medical Association, International Association of Bioethics)
Answer: Hippocratic Oath (BB 2)
2. What are the three types of valid consent for human participation in research?
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary (BB 83)
3. Sandel's deepest moral objection to enhancement is its alleged disfigurement of what relation?
Answer: parent-child relationship (pg. 46)
(More questions to follow in the comments)
Answer: Hippocratic Oath (BB 2)
2. What are the three types of valid consent for human participation in research?
Answer: Competent, Informed and Voluntary (BB 83)
3. Sandel's deepest moral objection to enhancement is its alleged disfigurement of what relation?
Answer: parent-child relationship (pg. 46)
(More questions to follow in the comments)
Friday, February 20, 2015
"A Mother’s Battle Against Medical Errors"
Hundreds of thousands of people in the U.S. die from medical errors every year. It is the third leading cause of death in the United States.
Carole Hemmelgarn is on a mission to help medical professionals avoid errors. She says the healthcare system failed her family and her daughter.
“I had a 9-year-old daughter, named Alyssa, and she was diagnosed with leukemia on a Monday and she died 10 days later,” said Hemmelgarn.
Listen:
Here&Now
Carole Hemmelgarn is on a mission to help medical professionals avoid errors. She says the healthcare system failed her family and her daughter.
“I had a 9-year-old daughter, named Alyssa, and she was diagnosed with leukemia on a Monday and she died 10 days later,” said Hemmelgarn.
Listen:
Here&Now
Thursday, February 19, 2015
The case against perfection, ch. 3 Designer children, Designing parents
Fact questions
1. Parenthood, more than other human relationships, teaches what the theologian William F. May calls an "____________________________________". (p.45)
2. What are the two aspects of parental love? (p.49)
3. Richard Williams and Earl Woods are examples of _____________________, bent on making champions of their children (p. 52)
4. (T/F) From 1992 to 2001, Princeton, a leading test prep company, saw its gross revenues increase 225 percent. (p.55)
5. Name one of the drugs used for ADHD that was given as an example in the chapter 3. (p.59)
Discussion Questions
1. Do you believe that our society is encouraging hyperparenting and what can we do to control it?
2. Children are consider gifts and blessings, do parents have the right to change and modify any aspect of their life?
3. Parents who want to genetically enhance their children; are they doing it for the well being of their child or is it their selfish desires for a perfect child?
Fact questions
1. Parenthood, more than other human relationships, teaches what the theologian William F. May calls an "____________________________________". (p.45)
2. What are the two aspects of parental love? (p.49)
3. Richard Williams and Earl Woods are examples of _____________________, bent on making champions of their children (p. 52)
4. (T/F) From 1992 to 2001, Princeton, a leading test prep company, saw its gross revenues increase 225 percent. (p.55)
5. Name one of the drugs used for ADHD that was given as an example in the chapter 3. (p.59)
Discussion Questions
1. Do you believe that our society is encouraging hyperparenting and what can we do to control it?
2. Children are consider gifts and blessings, do parents have the right to change and modify any aspect of their life?
3. Parents who want to genetically enhance their children; are they doing it for the well being of their child or is it their selfish desires for a perfect child?
DQ: If the option to give an offspring the best genetics is available and very financially affordable, is it morally wrong to deny the offspring of those genetics?
DQ: When/where is it appropriate to "draw the line" when it comes to ethical dilemmas of medicine? In other words, why is it okay to provide certain "tiers" of healthcare to a patient (such as IV injection, blood pressure medication, surgery, etc.) but NOT okay to provide other "tiers" of healthcare (i.e. genetic modification)? Why is one okay, but not the other? Is it more logical to either support all or none?
DQ: When/where is it appropriate to "draw the line" when it comes to ethical dilemmas of medicine? In other words, why is it okay to provide certain "tiers" of healthcare to a patient (such as IV injection, blood pressure medication, surgery, etc.) but NOT okay to provide other "tiers" of healthcare (i.e. genetic modification)? Why is one okay, but not the other? Is it more logical to either support all or none?
The case against perfection ch. 2 Bionic Athletes
Fact questions
1. In 1999 _____ _____ underwent lasik eye surgery to improve his vision and he won his next five tournaments. (p.30)
2. What corporation now sponsors a high-tech training experiment in a hermetically sealed " altitude house" in Portland, Oregon? (p.32)
3. What does the autor say about spectacles in sports? (p.37)
4. What is the effect of the beta-blockers taken for stage performance? (p.39)
Discussion Questions
1. Is there a way that bioengineering and technology can highlight the talents and skills that distinguish the best players instead of obscuring it?
2. Will bioengineering turn sports into a spectacle instead of a true test of talent and effort?
3.Do you think that bioengineering will create a big divide between athletes who are genetically engineered and athletes who are natually gifted?
Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Article and Questions
Here's an article on Ritalin use.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/medicating/readings/publicinterest.html
FQ:
(AP 59) True or False: It is estimated that 5 to 6 percent of children under 18 are prescribed to Ritalin and other stimulants.
DQ:
Are hyperparenting and genetic manipulation different from one another? Is planning out the career path/life for your children, like Richard Williams, any different than controlling them by genetic manipulation?
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/medicating/readings/publicinterest.html
FQ:
(AP 59) True or False: It is estimated that 5 to 6 percent of children under 18 are prescribed to Ritalin and other stimulants.
DQ:
Are hyperparenting and genetic manipulation different from one another? Is planning out the career path/life for your children, like Richard Williams, any different than controlling them by genetic manipulation?
Tuesday, February 17, 2015
The Case Agianst Perfection, Chapter 2
FQ: What was the goal of the "altitude house"?
FQ: The line: "kiss of death for good singing," was referring to singers having surgery to improve their vocal chords. (T/F)
DQ: Would separating genetically enhanced sports from non-genetically altered sports be successful?
DQ: In terms of technological innovations, including genetic enhancements, how can we tell between changes that will help improve life for everyone from changes that will only improve life for the individual?
Monday, February 16, 2015
McDonald's Immortal Hamburgers
I know this isn't dealing with anything bioethical, but I do know on our peripatetic walk on Thursday we got around to GMOS and McDonald's came up. I found a link talking about how their burgers (and food in general) never seem to mold or rot. Maybe you'll be interested in knowing the how's as well, sorry if this ruins their "food" for you.
http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/heres-why-mcdonalds-burgers-don-t-rot
http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/heres-why-mcdonalds-burgers-don-t-rot
Sunday, February 15, 2015
Peripatetic Discussion 2/12
We took an adventure through the library for our peripatetic
discussion this afternoon. While roaming through each floor our main topic was
focused on bioengineering and the ethics of genetic enhancement. Our first hit
of the topic was the situation of two deaf mothers choosing a deaf sperm donor
for their child in order for the child to connect better with the parents. The
major question of this decision is whether it is ethically right to this. The
first, and most prominent, argument was that it can in no way be right to
choose a child’s trait to be one that may hinder them for the rest of their
life, especially in a situation where the child has no choice. A counter
argument was that it is the parent’s choice for the child and deaf parents
would have a different perspective on deafness as a deficiency and in many
cases may even desire such a trait for the child to better understand and
connect to the parents in the world they see and will teach to them.
The discussion then continued to the idea of how it may be unethical
in the majority’s eyes to choose such a trait, is it ethical to choose
enhancements for specific traits the child also would not have a choice in?
Even though we may be able to choose numerous different traits for our
children, that does not mean we necessarily should. How do we know our child
will want to be musically talented, faster, or have larger muscles than they
would have had originally?
As we continued up the stairs of the library to stretch our
muscles, the discussion transitioned to future regulation of genetic
engineering. We discussed whether government would ever be able to control
genetic enhancements once the technology has evolved enough to be a choice for
future parents. As long as individuals are able to participate in medical
tourism, any country’s regulation of genetic engineering would be ineffective.
Saturday, February 14, 2015
Jindal, antiabortion activists block Planned Parenthood in New Orleans
Jindal, antiabortion activists block Planned Parenthood in New Orleans
It seems to me that there is a serious abortion issue going on in New Orleans, Louisiana. This is what the Washington Post had to say about the issue:
"NEW ORLEANS — Planned Parenthood began construction here last year on a clinic that would perform abortions and provide other medical services for women. “High-Quality, Affordable Health Care for New Orleans,” a sign promised. “Seeing Patients Early 2015.”
That sign is now crumpled on the ground behind a chain-link fence at the project’s abandoned construction site, victim of efforts by Gov. Bobby Jindal (R) and other abortion opponents to block the clinic."
To read more on this issue, click the link below.
http://wapo.st/1vuqeIo "NEW ORLEANS — Planned Parenthood began construction here last year on a clinic that would perform abortions and provide other medical services for women. “High-Quality, Affordable Health Care for New Orleans,” a sign promised. “Seeing Patients Early 2015.”
That sign is now crumpled on the ground behind a chain-link fence at the project’s abandoned construction site, victim of efforts by Gov. Bobby Jindal (R) and other abortion opponents to block the clinic."
To read more on this issue, click the link below.
Friday, February 13, 2015
Bradley becomes Chelsea-"Be all that you can be," indeed
Posted for Ramsey Ferguson:
In a first for the Army, Chelsea Manning, the convicted national-security secrets leaker, has been approved for hormone therapy for transition to a woman at the Army's Fort Leavenworth prison, according to a memo obtained Thursday by USA TODAY.
Manning remains a soldier as well as an inmate.
"After carefully considering the recommendation that (hormone treatment) is medically appropriate and necessary, and weighing all associated safety and security risks presented, I approve adding (hormone treatment) to Inmate Manning's treatment plan," Col. Erica Nelson, the commandant of the Fort Leavenworth Disciplinary Barracks in Kansas, wrote in a Feb. 5 memo.
Formerly named Bradley Manning, the soldier was convicted of sending classified documents to anti-secrecy website WikiLeaks. Manning is serving a 35-year prison sentence and is eligible for parole in about seven years...
Paradox of Healthcare
Jason, Erica, Yvonne and I chose to work on the paradox of healthcare. We will discuss the American healthcare system, its capabilities and inconsistencies, and compare it to other healthcare systems outside the USA. We will further discuss which countries we will do a bit a research on to compare systems.
Thursday, February 12, 2015
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

4. Sandel thinks Lasik surgery to correct normal vision would be an acceptable enhancement for a golfer under what condition? 31
5. Does Sandel allege an ethical problem with mega-calorie diets? 35
4. Does Sandel consider genetic engineering similar in spirit to expensive private schools & tutors, piano lessons, SAT prep, etc.? 52
5. "Parents of college students are out of control." 54 How so?
6. How do Ritalin, Adderall etc differ from recreational drugs of the past? 60-61
2. How much did Genetic Savings & Clone plan to charge for cloned canines? 5
3. According to what objection is genetic engineering objectionable because "designer children" are not fully free? OR, Why does Sandel not find this objection persuasive? 7
4. Which famous contemporary philosopher coined the term speciesism? 122
2. What's the leading global cause of death among women of reproductive age? (49)
4. What ethical perspective did Nel Noddings (supported by Carol Gilligan's research) describe as the "feminine approach"? (55)
5. What's a furor therapeuticus? (56)
6. Does Campbell consider the outlawing of female genital mutilation culturally insensitive? (58)
2. Which theory has been dominant in bioethics and often used by many health professionals?
3. In deontological theory, what is the difference between hypothetical and categorical imperatives?
6. What more do we want from a moral theory than Kant gives us?
6. Bioethics has expanded its focus from an originally narrower interest in what relationship? (BB 8)